Dear Mr. & Mrs. MS Lutheran Minister,
It’s been nearly a month since our children ended their relationship, and with the passing of time I now feel like I’m finally able to say a few things that would not have been appropriate for me to express before. I do hope you bear with me through what may become a lengthy correspondence, because you will find that my message is truly one of love and understanding.
Your son let us know some time ago about your concern and disapproval over our daughter’s church attendance records. Plainly put, she doesn’t attend, and that was distressing news for you to hear. I’m sorry that it upset you so, but there really is a simple explanation for the situation. On weekends, my daughter stays with her biological father, and while he professes to be a good Christian man, for some reason he does not allow her to attend church. Since she is still a minor, she has very little say in the matter. She has even had friends offer to take her with them, but all such efforts are ignored or refused. Frankly, it has always made me wonder what one does to become a “good Christian,” but I suppose that is besides the point.
If the situation was different, and she was with me on the weekends, I would have no problem with her attending church. Of course, I am not, nor have I ever claimed to be, a good Christian. In fact, I am just the opposite. I am a self-recognized sinner. No matter how hard I try to be good, my sins still wash over me like a waterfall in a never-ending torrent. There is rarely a time when I am not sinning in thought, word, or deed. It’s sad really, but my human faults make it impossible for me to free myself from sin.
However, before you feel any righteous justification for your feelings toward my daughter and my family, let me just say that the only thing that differs between you and I is that I recognize and acknowledge my imperfect nature. I know I am sinful, and that only through the grace of God can I possibly be saved. With him I can hope to be more than I am, but that only happens when I admit I am not perfect, and never will be. Even with his help I am a less than shining example of what a servant of God should be, but even so, he still loves me.
I wish I could express to you how wonderful it is to know that I am loved by one so great, when I am completely undeserving. I don’t have to be perfect, I can go to my Father, bare myself completely to him, and he forgives me. It’s liberating to not have to be ashamed of myself, because no matter how huge my mistakes may be, he loves me anyway. You (along with other people) may not forgive me for the things I’ve done in my life, but God will never hold my faults against me. It’s a miracle really, when you think about it, to not have to hide who you are, or what you’ve done, because to the most important judge, it just doesn’t matter.
Because I have received such great things from God’s unconditional love, I have tried very hard to emulate his example as I’ve raised my children. They can be open and honest with me without fear of recrimination. I have never once been yelled at by my heavenly Father when I’ve totally messed up my life, so I try to act accordingly with my children. I’m not always successful (after all I’m only human), but it is the standard I try to live by. Therefore it comes as no shock to me to learn that my children aren’t perfect. In fact, they’re usually the ones who let me know they’ve made mistakes. Again, I follow God’s example and instead of telling them what to do, I try to help guide them to the right choices, like God did for me when he gave me his word in the Bible.
You see, God doesn’t tell me that I have to do certain things, he doesn’t try to live my life for me. He tells me (in the Bible) how he would like me to behave, and then forgives me when I mess it up. He lets me make mistakes and learn from them, so that I can come to him of my own free will. He knew from the very beginning that true love cannot be forced on his children, we have to discover and choose it for ourselves.
So it came as no surprise to me when you called on Thanksgiving to let me know that my daughter had made mistakes. I was already aware of them as we had been talking extensively about the events that transpired. What did surprise me however, was that you were unaware of the mistakes your own family had made. You were filled with recriminations against my daughter, and refused to accept the fact that your son may have also played a role in the situation.
“Judge not, that you be not judged. For with the judgment you pronounce you will be judged, and with the measure you use it will be measured to you. Why do you see the speck that is in your brother’s eye, but do not notice the log that is in your own eye? Or how can you say to your brother, ‘Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ when there is the log in your own eye? You hypocrite, first take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother’s eye.” Matt 7:1-5 (ESV)
I would never have dreamed of calling you and listing your child’s faults, or telling you how to raise your children. Until I am sin free, it’s just not my place to judge other people, and I try my best to live by the above advice that my lord has given me. Perhaps it’s because I’m not a “good Christian” though, because I do find that I receive a lot of unsolicited advice from the people who live under that banner.
In closing, I’d like to thank you. You see, my daughter had hoped she could be good enough to gain your acceptance. She knew that as a pastor of a church you would expect certain things from anyone who was dating your son. In the end, she learned she wasn’t perfect enough to fit into your family. She is just a lowly sinner, and through her acceptance of that fact she is now learning the miracle of God’s never-ending grace and love. Unfortunately that miracle comes tainted with a new understanding of the hypocrisy of “good Christians.”
I wish nothing but the best for you and your family, and I hope that someday you are blessed with the knowledge that you don’t have to be perfect to be a child of God.